Monday 23 April 2012

How successful was Pakistan in its relationship with China between 1947 and 1999? [14]


Pakistan recognized the communist government of China in 1950 and supported it in regaining the UNO membership. During 1956-60, leaders of both countries visited each other's country to strengthen economic and cultural relations. In 1963, the boundary line between the two countries was demarcated to avoid any conflict in future. A series of trade agreements were signed in 1960s. China granted $60 million interest free loan and became the world's largest importer of Pakistan's cotton. Pakistan imported industrial machinery and developed the Heavy Mechanical Complex at Taxila. Pakistan International Airline started regular flights to China which resulted in increased business. Kara Koram Highway is the road link that flourishes trade and tourism between the two countries. 


China has supported Pakistan's stand on Kashmir issue. During the 1965 war with India, China supplied military aid to Pakistan along with diplomatic assistance. In 1986, the two countries signed a nuclear cooperation treaty which is an indication of very good relations. China gave the Chashma Nuclear Power Plant to Pakistan, constructed near Mianwali and which started operation in 1999. 


Now coming to the weaker side, Pakistan did not have good relations with China in its early few years after independence due to pro-American policies (USA and China were rivals). In 1959 Pakistan condemned military action in Tibet which was a displeasure for China. In the 1971 war with India, China did not support Pakistan due to former USSR pressure who supported India. During 1990s China wanted Pakistan to resolve its issue of Kashmir with India. Perhaps she wanted a compromise which was a cause of resentment for Pakistan. 


Conclusively, it can be said that as a whole Pakistan has maintained cordial relations with China. The two countries have been living in harmony. Delegations from almost all walks of life exchanged visits. Up to 1999, there were strong economic, trade and cultural ties between the two countries. And Pakistan received significant military and industrial equipment from China. 

17 comments:

  1. Replies
    1. According to the mark scheme I think it's perfect. Moreover the construction of paragraphs is also good

      Delete
    2. According to the mark scheme I think it's perfect. Moreover the construction of paragraphs is also good

      Delete
    3. it is supposed to be laconic on this website

      Delete
  2. How many marks could this answer achieve

    ReplyDelete
  3. I heard an answer of 14 marks is supposed to have 8 paragraphs, 7 for explanation, 1 for evaluation. And considering this question, since relations with china were mostly good, 4 paragraphs for successes and 3 for failures, 1 for your evaluation. What you have posted seems unreliable considering the info i have. Tell me if you think anything i've mentioned is wrong though.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In a 14 mark answer you're supposed to have 5-6 paragraphs, 4-5 for relevant points and explanation+evaluation and one paragraph for conclusion. 3 paragraphs for failures with China would be a lot considering there were only like 3-4 failures which could be fitted in 2 paragraphs or even 1 without seeming extended too much.

      Delete
    2. Quality over quantity

      Delete
  4. this is actually quite good, 14 marks is supposed to have an intro, then separate paragraphs for the successes or failure in this case and the conclusion. I was hoping for an introduction as well but this is good.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Pakistan has a long and strong relationship with China. The long-standing ties between the two countries have been mutually beneficial.
    Pakistan recognized the communist government of China in 1950 and supported it in regaining the UNO membership. During 1956-60, leaders of both countries visited each other's country to strengthen economic and cultural relations.
    In 1963, the boundary line between the two countries was demarcated to avoid any conflict in future. A series of trade agreements were signed in 1960s. China granted $60 million interest free loan and became the world's largest importer of Pakistan's cotton. Pakistan imported industrial machinery and developed the Heavy Mechanical Complex at Taxila. Pakistan International Airline started regular flights to China which resulted in increased business. Kara Koram Highway is the road link that flourishes trade and tourism between the two countries.
    1963 Historic Visit of Foreign Minister Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto to China made it was even better as this showed that pakistan is willing to develope their relationship.1964 Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) started its flights to Beijing, becoming the first non-communist country airline to fly from Beijing, entering into a new era of linkages between the two countries. Pakistan was the window for China to interact with the rest of world.1965 Agreement on Cultural Cooperation signed, promoting understanding and harmony.China has supported Pakistan's stand on Kashmir issue. During the 1965 war with India, China supplied military aid to Pakistan along with diplomatic assistance.
    1976 Agreement on Scientific and Cultural Cooperation signed, opening huge opportunities for Pakistani scientists and students. 1978 The Karakoram Highway, a construction miracle, linking mountainous Northern Pakistan with Western China officially opened, linking China to the Arabian Ocean. Again this was mutually beneficial as pakistan could easily trade and china could send its goods to the world through the sea.
    1989 The two countries sign an agreement on Reciprocal Encouragement and Protection of Investments. China is the largest investor in Pakistan. In 1986, the two countries signed a nuclear cooperation treaty which is an indication of very good relationship.
    1995 Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto visits China as a special guest to attend the 4th Women's Conference in Beijing, bring the women of the two friendly nations close to each other. In 1999 The contract to jointly develop and produce the JF-17 was signed, a landmark event for Pakistan's defense Industry.China gave the Chashma Nuclear Power Plant to Pakistan, constructed near Mianwali and which started operation in 1999.
    Now coming to the weaker side, Pakistan did not have good relations with China in its early few years after independence due to pro-American policies (USA and China were rivals). In 1959 Pakistan condemned military action in Tibet which was a displeasure for China. In the 1971 war with India, China did not support Pakistan due to former USSR pressure who supported India. During 1990s China wanted Pakistan to resolve its issue of Kashmir with India. Perhaps she wanted a compromise which was a cause of resentment for Pakistan.
    Conclusively, it can be said that as a whole Pakistan has maintained cordial relations with China. The two countries have been living in harmony. Delegations from almost all walks of life exchanged visits. Up to 1999, there were strong economic, trade and cultural ties between the two countries. And Pakistan received significant military and industrial equipment from China.




    I edited it a bit, the ans was really good but some points were missing which i added.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Fine answer though a few points of failures need elaboration.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Good answer, really helpful

    ReplyDelete