Showing posts with label 03-War of 1857. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 03-War of 1857. Show all posts

Friday, 25 January 2013

‘The War of Independence of 1857 achieved nothing’. Give reasons why you might agree and disagree with this statement. [14] (Past Paper, October 2002: Q1/c)


The war of independence 1857 was a failure. The uprising was successfully crushed by the British troops in all parts of India within a few months. Countless Indians lost their lives. Muslims were victims of worst atrocities after the war ended because the British blamed them responsible for the revolt. They were hanged in large number; their properties were confiscated and many were driven out of jobs. The war brought utter destruction to the still existing powerless Mughal King and the symbolic Mughal Empire.

Although the uprising failed in driving the British out of India, but it won’t be just to say that it achieved nothing. It brought about significant changes in policy and administration of the British government in India. The exploitative role of East India Company came to an end. The subcontinent went under direct control of the British Crown. Constitutional reforms were introduced involving Indians in the affairs of the state on limited scale. The governor-general was to be called Viceroy and a Secretary of State for Indian affairs was nominated with a council of 15 members. These changes were made to address concerns of Indian people. The hated “doctrine of lapse” was abolished which was aimed at grabbing Indian territories.

The war became a historic event promoting nationalism and patriotism in Indians. It created a strong urge in the Indians to break the shackles of slavery. At the same time Indian leaders came to know that the British are too powerful to be overthrown through armed struggle. Therefore, they changed their strategy and started political struggle forming Indian National Congress in 1885 followed by All India Muslim League in 1906. Their urge for freedom culminated in independence of the subcontinent 90 years after the 1857 war.

[Conclusion] Instead of saying “nothing” I would like to say that the war achieved “little” in terms of immediate returns. 

Monday, 10 September 2012

Briefly explain three reasons for the War of Independence of 1857. [7] (Past Paper, June 2000: Q1/b)


[Financial Exploitation] The British were financially exploiting the Indians. Cotton produced in India was taken to the textile industries in Britain. As a result, the local cotton industries collapsed which created unemployment and poverty. Obviously, this was a cause of immense displeasure for the Indians. Moreover, heavy taxes were imposed on peasants and small landowners which were very difficult for them to pay. Native Indians were not given jobs in the Civil Services. These activities were adding into the anger of Indian people.

[Religious Attack] Christian missionaries were allowed to work anywhere in the Indian subcontinent. Their main objective was to preach Christianity. They were criticizing the beliefs of Muslims, Hindus, Sikhs and other casts and the ways they worshipped. They established schools where local Indians were continuously tried to convert to Christianity. These actions outraged the different religious groups living in India.

[Racial Discrimination] Most of the British army consisted of local sepoys. They were always supervised by British officers who were very arrogant. They considered themselves racially superior over the Indians and culturally more advanced and civilized nation. They even didn’t like to speak with the sepoys in their native language. The sepoys disliked their attitude and started hating them.

Saturday, 17 March 2012

Was a lack of unity amongst the Indians the main reason for the failure of the War of Independence 1857-58? Explain your answer. [14]

During the War of Independence 1857, there was a complete lack of unity among the fighting groups though all were fighting against a common enemy, the British soldiers. There was no coordination between different regions of unrest and no attempts were made to bring their strengths together. Some local leaders even helped the British in the war e.g. the ruler of Kashmir sent 2000 troops on the British side. However, there were also some other reasons for the failure of the war.


The sudden outbreak of 1857 war had no defined goals or planning. Different groups were fighting for different causes. Most of the Muslims wanted to restore the Mughal ruler, Bahadur Shah Zafar, but Hindus and Sikhs were not ready to fight for restoring the Muslim Mughal Empire. Many princes were interested in regaining their own feudal powers. A good number of ordinary people remained neutral i.e. they did not take part in the uprising. 


There was no central leadership to motivate people to join the rebellion. There was no central command to provide guidelines, prepare action planes or coordinate between different areas of revolt. The final reason is that the British were very strong to defeat, and they were very determined to suppress the revolt. 


The most important reason for the failure of the war was the strength and position of the British. They were good planners of war strategies. They had sound financial resources and could fight long wars. They had latest warfare tools and their troops were experienced and highly trained in modern methods of fighting. They had efficient means of communication e.g. railways for quick deployment of troops. They had skilled diplomats who knew the techniques of gaining support of local rulers.